By Glenda Taylor | Updated Jun 14, 2023 10:27 AM
We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs. Learn more. Steel Pipe Carbon
If you’ve ever had to install shelving or hang picture frames, you’ve more than likely had to find out where the studs were located behind the drywall. Generally, it’s quicker and more reliable to use a tool specially designed for the purpose—a stud finder.
We decided to test a slew of them to help readers find one that suits their needs. I tested magnetic and electronic models in my quest to find the best stud finder options out there. Read on to learn what to look for in a stud finder, and find out which popular models scored highest during my tests.
To make this list of the best stud finders, each one of the tools I tested had to be highly accurate. Users rely on wall stud finders to pinpoint the location of studs concealed beneath the drywall because deciding how to find a stud can be difficult without one of these handy tools.
I wanted to create a test situation that was very close to the situation DIYers and pros face when trying to find hidden studs, so I built a facsimile of a stud wall. I framed up a test board with several vertical studs and attached standard, ½-inch drywall to the bottom half of the studs. That allowed me to test the tools on the drywall while noting how accurate they were. In addition, to test for live wires, I ran the stud finders (the ones with wire-finding functions) over a section of wall in my home where I know electrical wires run.
I scored each stud finder on accuracy, ease of use, and screen visibility, and I recorded the scores on a rubric. At the end of the testing, I added up the scores for each stud finder and used them to categorize the tools based on their best use.
I was pleasantly surprised to find that the majority of stud finders tested were accurate and dependable. The ones that weren’t didn’t make this list. The following stud finders detect anything from steel studs and fasteners to live wires and pipes. Some even detect double-stud construction. To test the degree of accuracy, I constructed a test wall that mimicked the configuration of an actual wall to see how precise the stud finders were. Find out what the tests revealed and why the following stud finders made it on the list of Top Picks.
Never miss a stud again. For those who need to find the center of a stud, either for securely hanging artwork or cutting the drywall along the stud’s centerline, the Zircon Stud Finder shines. I inserted a 9-volt battery, and the stud finder was ready to go. As I slid the tool across the surface of the test wall, diagonal lines appeared on either side of the digital display to indicate the sensors were moving over a stud. As soon as I reached the stud’s center, the lines met in a “V,” and a lighted red arrow appeared on the wall above.
The red arrow was right on the center of the stud and had I inserted a nail or screw at that point, it would have been dead-on. I moved on to testing for repeat accuracy on a regular wall. I started at one end of the wall and made an entire scan from side to side. Every time the Zircon tagged the center of a stud, I marked the wall with a pencil. To my amazement, the marks were almost exactly 16 inches apart (within a 1/16 inch). This was without needing to calibrate the tool, but the Zircon does come with an auto-calibration feature if it ever needs to be recalibrated for accuracy.
The Zircon stud finder also did an excellent job of detecting live wires, and while I didn’t have any metal studs to scan for, the stud finder detected steel rebar in a concrete planter.
Note: Since we conducted our tests, a newer model Zircon MultiScanner A250c became available. Though I didn’t test it, Zircon appears to have updated the backlit screen to indicate the scanning mode based on the color of the display—blue for metal scanning, green when scanning for wood studs, and red when searching for live wires. This appears to be a smart addition, and I look forward to trying it out in the future.
Get the Zircon stud finder at Amazon.
This basic Craftsman Stud Finder doesn’t come with a lot of bells and whistles, but it gets the job done—and at a very attractive price point. I was a bit surprised on the first inspection of the Craftsman stud finder; it weighs less than 4 ounces, and it’s just 5½ inches long. I didn’t hold out much hope that it would do the job. I was wrong.
I put a 9-volt battery in the stud finder and pressed the power button on the side. A beep and a green light on the top lit up to indicate the stud finder was ready to go to work. With this stud finder, I discovered the user has to hold the power button down while scanning—let off the button and the tool goes back to sleep.
I ran the Craftsman stud finder over the test wall and then over a standard wall. When the sensor detected the edge of a stud, the tool emitted a beep, and the “Edge” light on the front lit up. This wall scanner comes with an edge sensor only, but that’s all you need to find a stud. A standard 2-by-4 stud is 1½ inches thick, so by measuring 0.75 inches from where the Craftsman indicates the edge of a stud, you’ll find the center. For the cost, you can’t beat the accuracy.
Get the Craftsman stud finder at Amazon or Lowe’s.
On first use, I was a little surprised the Vivreal Stud Finder didn’t detect the stud behind the test wall. On further inspection, it was a blatant case of user error. The instructions very clearly say the tool must be calibrated before every scan. That was a simple matter of selecting the mode I was scanning for (wood stud) and then holding the device against the wall while depressing the scan button on the side. In a few seconds, the tool beeped, indicating calibration was complete, and I rescanned the test wall. The Vivreal wall scanner showed a series of horizontal bars as the scanner neared the stud and a beep when it found the stud’s center.
On the whole-wall test, the Vivreal wall scanner was also highly accurate, finding the center of each stud. It also found the wires running to the light switch. The back of the stud finder features three thin felt pads, which make it slide effortlessly across the wall.
The Vivreal Wall Scanner stands out for its versatility. It features four scanning types (stud, metal, wire, and deep-scan mode) and comes with a graphical LCD display. Users can select the mode, adjust the signal strength, or perform automatic calibration. This stud finder is a worthy option for a do-it-yourselfer with a lengthy to-do list.
Get the Vivreal wall scanner at Amazon.
Nothing could be simpler, or more accurate, than the Franklin Sensors ProSensor Stud Finder. I already had this stud finder in my toolbox, but I wanted to know if its exceptional accuracy extended to the updated models. I wasn’t disappointed. I loaded the Franklin stud finder up with two AA batteries and started testing.
To use the ProSensor stud finder, the user needs to depress the scan button on the side (or on the top, as I typically hold it) and pass the tool over the wall. The nicest thing about the ProSensor is that its scan bed is 7.5 inches long, and the finder contains multiple sensors. A series of 13 lights are located along the top of this Franklin stud finder, and as the tool passes over a stud, the corresponding light is illuminated. This allowed me to detect both single-stud and double-stud framing members within the test wall. In addition, a 7.5-inch ruler is etched into the top of the stud finder so users can check measurements.
The key to the precision of the ProSensor is the line of LED lights that runs along the tool. With the ProSensor, it’s possible to detect and distinguish between studs located within a few inches of one another, as is often the case near a door or in the corner of a room, making this stud detector well suited for remodeling contractors who need to find the locations of multiple framing configurations.
Get the Franklin Sensors stud finder at Amazon or Franklin Sensors.
I found the Bosch Digital Multi-Scanner highly accurate for detecting a range of materials, even materials found in thicker walls. Like many electronic stud finders, the Bosch takes a 9-volt battery to run all its functions. It comes with user-friendly images on the front to detect wood, metal, and live wire, making it easy to use the device even without reading the instructions.
One of the features I liked most about the Bosch stud finder is its actual power button. There’s nothing for the user to hold down while scanning. Use the power button to turn the tool on, and it stays on until you turn it off. While this may lead to batteries running down more quickly if the device is inadvertently left on, I liked this feature immensely. With an always-on power button, I could hold the tool the way I wanted to rather than needing to grasp it awkwardly to keep a button depressed.
The Bosch stud finder is self-calibrating. Turn it on, select the mode, and then hold it in place on the wall for a few seconds to calibrate it. During scanning, when the tool neared a stud, an orange light ring on the face lit up. As I slid the device over the stud, the light ring turned red, and the stud finder emitted a beep. When the tool was directly over the stud, the word “Center” appeared on the LCD display.
The Bosch stud finder also hit on live wiring in the wall and on metal fasteners in wood studs. In addition, this multiuse stud finder can turn on a backlight in the display and mute the beeping noise, making it well suited for low-light situations or where someone might find the beeping distracting.
Get the Bosch stud finder at Amazon or The Home Depot.
Say goodbye to crooked picture frames. Unlike other stud finders, the Black+Decker Stud Finder features an edge-type sensor, and the tool comes with a self-leveling, horizontal laser line. Together, the two functions make an impressive team for hanging a series of pictures or other artwork.
It features self-calibration that requires holding the tool against the wall and then depressing the power button and holding it down for a few seconds. The word “Initializing” flashes across the red-backlit LCD screen, quickly followed by the word “Ready.” The tool is then ready to begin scanning.
I tested the Black & Decker on the test wall to determine its accuracy. As I moved the stud finder toward the stud, a series of lines appeared at the outer edges of the screen to indicate the edge of a stud was detected, and the words “Stud found” appeared on the screen. To find the center of the stud, I marked the wall when the finder detected one edge, and then I scanned from the other side and did the same thing. The center was right between the two marks.
Then, I tried the laser, and I was sold. Here’s how easy it is to use—in the upper center of the stud finder is a clear plastic depression with a hole in the very middle. I made a mark with a pencil on the wall and then lined up the hole in the stud finder with the pencil mark. I then switched on the laser function from a button on the side—a bright red laser beam shone out horizontally.
I had my helper make a pencil mark about 4 feet away on the laser line. I then inserted two nails in each of the marks and tied a taut string between them. I checked the level of the string with my carpenter’s level, and it was accurate. For those who need to be able to define a horizontal level and detect wood and metal studs, the Black+Decker stud finder does the trick.
Get the Black+Decker stud finder at Amazon.
No batteries? No problem. This magnetic stud finder is super-portable and designed to detect either metal studs or the metal fasteners in the studs, making it among the best options for those who need to locate studs without worrying about batteries running down.
On the test wall, the C.H. Hanson Magnetic Stud Finder stuck by itself to the drywall when it was placed over the location of a metal fastener. I moved the tiny stud finder around in large swooping circles on a standard wall and eventually felt a magnetic pull; it took maybe 15 to 20 seconds.
The small C.H. Hanson magnetic stud finder is an excellent backup for an electronic stud finder, and if carrying space in a toolbox or tool belt is at a premium, it won’t take up a lot of room. While some magnetic stud finders feature only one magnet, this one includes two, one at each end. The CH Hanson also includes a built-in bubble level, which makes the next step—mounting something on the wall—that much easier. When you’re done with it, slip the compact 3-inch-long tool in your pocket or stash it in your kitchen junk drawer until you need it again.
Get the C.H. Hanson magnetic stud finder at Ace Hardware.
Stud finders fall into two basic categories based on the method they use for stud detection, either magnetic or electronic. One’s not inherently better than the other; instead, each one offers different benefits for different situations. We tested both types of tools in our hands-on tests with some pretty eye-opening results, so don’t miss those tests and reviews below our guide.
Magnetic stud finders use powerful rare earth magnets to detect the location of metal screws or nails that hold picture frames, mirrors, and drywall panels in place. As you slide this stud finder over a wall, it is magnetically attracted to any spot directly above a nail or screw—you will feel it pulling in that direction, and you may even see the stud finder stick! (Most magnetic stud finders are lightweight and have magnets powerful enough that they will hold through the drywall.)
Magnetic stud finders work to a depth of about ¾ inch, which is sufficient most of the time for finding studs in walls behind standard ½-inch or ⅝-inch drywall. When you locate a nail or screw, you’ve located a stud. Because drywall fasteners are located typically 12 to 16 inches apart, it’s recommended that you move a magnet-based stud finder over the wall in a sweeping “S” motion to more quickly detect one.
On the other hand, electronic stud finders rely on internal sensors rather than magnets to pinpoint the location of wood studs. They sense a change in density in the space behind the wall. The best stud finders are precalibrated and are ready to go right out of the package—after inserting batteries—but a few need to be calibrated to ensure precise results.
Though the technology may sound complicated, electronic stud finders are easy to use: Simply place the tool flat against the wall and move it slowly in a horizontal fashion. When it detects a stud, it will emit an audible alarm and produce a visual indicator, depending on the specific model.
Like all technology, electronic stud finders have seen many improvements from the time they appeared on the construction market in the 1990s. To pinpoint the location of a stud, an electronic stud finder uses sensors that detect a mass behind the wall. They may come with a single sensor, in which case they will detect only the edge of a stud, or they may come with multiple sensors, giving them the ability to detect both edges as well as the center of the stud. Both single sensor and multiple sensor stud finders perform well on average.
Sensors range in size. Stud finders with larger sensors have a few advantages, such as being able to cover a more expansive area and (sometimes) being able to penetrate thicker or more solid walls, such as plaster or concrete. Smaller sensors, on the other hand, can be highly accurate. For most home DIYers, sensor size is not an issue since a typical stud finder with smaller or larger sensors will be able to pinpoint studs behind drywall.
Today’s stud finders can also pack an extra punch: Many are outfitted with features that extend the usefulness of the stud finder and make it handier. From this list, identify the features you think could be the most helpful before settling on a stud finder that works.
Not everyone can reliably rap on the wall and find a stud—most can’t—so using a stud finder makes projects go more quickly. Those who are new to the world of electronic and magnetic stud finders are in for a treat. Consider a few questions before picking one out.
Electronic stud finders can often detect a stud through ceramic tiles, especially if the tool comes with deep mode. One of the best options for detecting through most materials is the Franklin Prosensor.
Standard wall framing is 16 inches apart, on-center (OC), meaning the center of one stud will be exactly 16 inches from the center of the next. Alternate spacing is 19.2 inches and 24 inches apart, OC.
That depends on the individual tool. Some beep when they detect the edge of a stud, while others beep when they detect the center of a stud. Some stud finders beep to let the user know they’ve just recalibrated.
Most, but not all. Some outlets come with boxes that are designed to fit in a hole cut through the drywall. A stud finder that detects both studs and live wires can tell the user if this type of outlet box is in use.
Bob Vila has been America’s Handyman since 1979. As the host of beloved and groundbreaking TV series including “This Old House” and “Bob Vila’s Home Again,” he popularized and became synonymous with “do-it-yourself” home improvement.
Over the course of his decades-long career, Bob Vila has helped millions of people build, renovate, repair, and live better each day—a tradition that continues today with expert yet accessible home advice. The Bob Vila team distills need-to-know information into project tutorials, maintenance guides, tool 101s, and more. These home and garden experts then thoroughly research, vet, and recommend products that support homeowners, renters, DIYers, and professionals in their to-do lists.
Articles may contain affiliate links which enable us to share in the revenue of any purchases made.
Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service.
Black Steel Pipe © 2023 Recurrent. All rights reserved.